Hard times always bring out the creativity in man. Necessity is the mother of invention. There are a slough of offers across the internet for cut price Kilimanjaro climbs being tendered by the lower two-thirds of climb market in Tanzania which caters for the bulk of the venture traffic.
This dovetails very neatly into the need for cheap climb options that would be the only way a lot of people could travel in this economic climate, but if a trip is offered below cost, and if survival is the key, then corners will be cut, and here are a few ways this is being achieved.
Short trips
This is a trick the has surfaced and submerged often over the years, and currently it is back at the surface breathing new life into the ailing bottom feeders that have always proliferated at the fringe of respectable Kili business. It is very simple, and here is how it works:
You pay for an 8-day trip and upon check-in at the national parks gate, usually with connivance of one of more TANAPA officials, your operator pays for only a 6-day trip. The crew are then under instructions to ensure that as many members of party as possible succumb to AMS (Acute Mountain Sickness) within those 6-days, which can be achieved in any number of ways, particularly among novice climbers. These are then hustled off the mountain which allows the outfitting company to retain the parks fees, not only for those paying packs themselves, but also the porters and guides for whom fees will also have been charged but not paid.
The obvious way to guard against this is to make sure the correct monies are paid at the gate and the correct registration completed. This not easy, particularly if a TANAPA official is in on it, but it is a precaution.
It is also worthwhile, particularly if you have been given younger guides whose attitude is less one of professionalism and experience than teenagers taking any job they can get, not taking as rote everything you are told. The signs of this type of guide are usually that they remain plugged into their MP3 player or transistor radios from beginning to end, have no particular answers to any queries, and are more interested in what kit they can beg than your well-being or enjoyment.
If you find yourself with this type of guide you need to take more control of your circumstances. If you are suffering obvious problems and your guide’s advice is go, go, go!, then pause and assert your status as a paying client and lay down the law. Do not be coerced or bulldozed into side excursion that you do not feel up to, and do not adhere to any suggestions of short cuts, truncated days or any other creative route finding that strays from the written itinerary.
A very common sight on the final stretch of the climb are climbers clearly on their last legs, fading in and out of consciousness, retching and weaving, but being pushed on by their guides in a manner that might on the surface seem inspirational, but is in reality extremely grubby. Here is why.
It is essential when setting off from Barafu Camp towards the summit to have with your group enough personnel qualified or experienced at high altitude to ensure that everyone has a shot of getting to the summit. Out of a group of ten packs at least five might drop out at various stages and need to be escorted down by someone who knows what they are doing. The remainder are then able to continue up with another guide, usually the lead guide, who knows what he or she is doing.
If a group of 10 packs is sent up on the last 6-hour slog to the summit with just one, or maybe two guides, in order that the whole group are not forced to return alongside the first casualty, the ailing member is put under enormous, and extremely dangerous pressure to continue. It is usually a very irritated party of climbers that has to return short of the summit thanks to the incapacity of one, or maybe two climbers.
Any climb outfitter worth its salt will provide a ratio of guides-to-climbers of three packs to one guide. Usually this is arranged so that the party is led by a ‘lead’ guide whose age and experience is sufficient to undertake the task. He will be supported by an assistant guide, or two, who are licensed, but gaining experience under the tutelage of the master.
Supporting these will be a clique of porters with ambitions to go through the licensing system who usually undertake the tasks of cook, camp manager and quartermaster, with the capacity to escort injured or weakened members of the climb party down if necessary, and otherwise to stand in as emergency guides in a crisis.
It is worth remembering the bulk of the porters you will have on your trip are part of the bottom rung of the climb fraternity, and for the most part they are an itinerate workforce with little mountain experience who do a trip or two when they need the cash and otherwise are lowland farmers or share croppers accustomed to the steppe. These are not men capable of any degree of professional mountaineering, and very much bring up the rear.
Another point worth remember is that there is a local industry is second hand kit, and your guides and porters will have their eye on what your might be relieved of from the onset. Requests for kit and tearful distress at low tips are a common feature of Kili, arm yourself with fore-knowledge, and do not give away kit you do not want to give away just because your petitioner looks like he might need it. Chances are he intends to sell it.
So these are just a couple of popular scams, let me know if you have experienced any others and I would be happy to compile a rouges gallery of naughty boys that do this kind of stuff.
So sad to here that there such people who do scam tourist and their fellow guides and porters. Climbing Kilimanjaro is not an easy task and I don’t think I will be happy if I get scammed after this hard work.
We just did this climb in mid June. Didn’t hear of any scams and our guides and porters were excellent. My only suggestion is to work with a reputable company. We worked with Africa Travel Resource who works with the African Walking Company who leads the climb. The guides and porters are treated well and apparently have to carry less weight than other companies.
Is anyone out there looking for a small group to join in Feb. 2010? Three of us - USA, machme route, Feb. 21-27. Any advise on companies too!
Please help us find a good one. Thanks!
I was actually thinking of that very same date. Feb.21-27. I think it coincides with the full moon. I’ve been looking at Mountain Kingdom and trying to find more info/references, but it’s not easy. Althought their contact has been helpful. I was leaning to the Lemosho route since it is more beautiful and has less people, but I read that the Machame is good too. I’m out of florida. As a single, I’d probably be looking to join a group.
I have booked for Feb. 21-27 on the Machame route with Zara tours. They are a bit more pricey than most but their reputation seems good. I am single, so I am also looking for people to join
If you want a really good guidebook on the mountain, go to http://www.climbmountkilimanjaro.com/ and check out the website of the book by Henry Stedman
Dear Gretchen,
I have 4 of my best friends from USA who will be climbing Kili come Feb,2010 using the same routes.The Tour Leader of that group is called Tom,email tvos1@me.com.They will be climbing with the Africa Veterans guides who are very experienced in Kili Climbing.You can contact them for more info about the exact dates.
Please read my respond to Gretchen and see whether you can join this group traveling with africa veterans.Contact this people for the prices and let them know that you have been referred so that they will not over charge.
We leave Germany tomorrow heading to Kili to start climbing Saturday. We used: http://www.kilimanjaro-shah.com which many of my friends have used in Djibouti and Germany as well, with no problems. We are paying $1550 for the climb (to include an extra altitude aclimation day) and a two day safari. We will summit on the 2nd, full moon as well.
Best of luck to you all.
Rob
We are planning a trip for the last week of June and the first week of July. Does anyone have recommendations on which tour groups to use?
Tourists Skip Kenya, Head to Tanzania
Climb Kilimanjaro for The Children's Society
Mt. Kilimanjaro Forum Thread for the week of October 16, 2006
World Leaders Climb Kilimanjaro
Caroline on A few Common Kili Scams
We are planning a trip for the last week of June and the first week of July. Does anyone have recomm...
Rob on A few Common Kili Scams
We leave Germany tomorrow heading to Kili to start climbing Saturday. We used: www.kilimanjaro-sha...
Mugo on A few Common Kili Scams
Please read my respond to Gretchen and see whether you can join this group traveling with africa vet...
Mugo on A few Common Kili Scams
Dear Gretchen, I have 4 of my best friends from USA who will be climbing Kili come Feb,2010 using...
sheila on The Pros and Cons of Diamox
can anyone who has climbed Kili tell me if there are any narrow ledges on the climb. I'm keen to do ...